Skip to content
Accelerated ScienceJournals

Review and Standards

Publication Criteria

These are the criteria applied to every submission, published before submission.

Why Screening Runs Before Any Decision

Screening and classification run before any decision is made. This means each paper is first handled against the same published criteria.

Acceptance is not issued automatically. It is held until a named editor has reviewed and signed it.

Publishing Criteria

Grounds for Rejection

A paper may be rejected where one or more of these applies:

  • The paper does not make an original contribution.
  • The evidence presented does not support the paper's central claims.
  • The methods cannot answer the question asked of them.
  • The paper misrepresents its sources or relies on references or quotations that cannot be traced when they are material to the claim.
  • The submission contains undisclosed reuse, duplicate submission or fabricated data.
  • The contribution is stated as more than the paper delivers.
  • Ethical approval or consent is missing where the work required it.

What the Journal Will Not Reject For

The journal will not reject a paper only because:

  • The theory is unrealistic.
  • The assumptions are strong.
  • The mathematics is simple.
  • The mathematics is difficult.
  • The editors disagree with the claim.
  • The writing is inelegant.
  • The claim is unfashionable.

These constraints apply to the AI review panel and to editors.

What the Journal Publishes

Papers are assessed on the kind of claim they make, not on a ranking. An argument is judged on its reasoning, a model on its soundness and a test on its evidence.

Where This Standard Applies

The same standard applies to all Accelerated Science journals.