Skip to content
Accelerated ScienceJournals

Review and Standards

How Review Works

Human-written, AI-assisted and AI-generated manuscripts are judged against the same published standards: originality, rigour, traceable sources, stated methods and clear claims.

The process is designed to make the basis of each decision clear. Authors are told what was assessed, what was found, what is required and what they can do next.

Review Stages

  1. 01

    Submission

    The manuscript is received and linked to the author’s account. From that point, the submission has a permanent record. A submission can be sent only to a journal that is open for submissions.

  2. 02

    Screening

    The manuscript is checked for completeness and for text written to influence an automated reader rather than support academic assessment. If the submission record or files need correction before review, the submission may be returned to the author as unsubmitted. A manuscript that is too short to assess or that contains text written to influence an automated reader is refused and the reason is stated.

  3. 03

    Classification

    The paper is classified by core discipline, sub-core discipline and the kind of contribution it makes. At each subsequent stage, the manuscript is evaluated using criteria appropriate to its type. For example, theoretical papers are assessed on their theoretical merits rather than against standards intended for empirical research.

  4. 04

    Panel Assessment

    A panel of AI reviewers assesses the paper against the published criteria and reviewer guidelines. Each AI reviewer has a defined role. A final AI editorial reviewer combines the panel assessments into one decision. If the paper can proceed, the decision sets out the Acceptance Requirements: the specific changes the paper must satisfy before acceptance.

  5. 05

    Revision

    The author revises the paper against the Acceptance Requirements and resubmits it. The revision is assessed on whether each requirement has been met. The decision letter states the deadline for the revision.

  6. 06

    Acceptance

    An acceptance is not issued automatically. It is held until a named editor has reviewed and signed it.

  7. 07

    Publication

    The corresponding author confirms the author list and metadata. Accepted papers are published open access under CC BY 4.0.

Measured turnaround by discipline will be published once enough decisions have been issued.

What Is Automated and What Is Not

Automated

Screening, classification and panel assessment are carried out by AI models. Their assessments are recorded with the submission.

Human

Every acceptance decision is reviewed and approved by a named human editor before it is issued. Before publication, the corresponding author must personally review and approve the final version and agree to the publication terms. This step cannot be completed by an AI agent or automated system on the author's behalf. All appeals are reviewed by a person.

In Development

Automated checking of references against bibliographic records, text-overlap checking against published literature, and computational checking of mathematics are in development. We do not describe a paper as having passed these checks until they are in place.

Outcomes

  1. Unsubmitted

    The submission is returned to the author before review because something in the submission record or files needs correction.

    This is not a rejection and does not assess the quality of the paper. The decision states what must be corrected. The author may correct the submission and send it again under the same submission record, where available.

  2. Desk Reject

    The paper does not meet the published criteria and cannot proceed. The decision gives the reasons.

  3. Revise and Resubmit

    The paper may proceed, but substantial changes are required. The decision lists them as Acceptance Requirements.

  4. Conditional Acceptance

    The paper is conditionally accepted, subject to satisfying the specific requirements stated in the decision letter. These requirements may involve minor or substantial revisions. Final acceptance is issued only after all requirements have been satisfied and a named editor has reviewed and signed the acceptance. Authors are not required to address additional requirements beyond those specified unless new issues arise from the revisions.

  5. Accept

    Once signed by a named editor, the paper is accepted for open-access publication under CC BY 4.0.

  6. A Better-Matched Journal

    Where a qualified paper belongs more closely to another Accelerated Science journal, the decision may recommend publication there.

Every outcome includes reasons. Unsubmitted is an administrative status before review. Outcomes other than acceptance are issued from the panel’s assessment and may be appealed. A decision does not state or imply that the paper will be accepted by another journal or publisher.

After an Unsuccessful Outcome

Authors receive the reasons for the outcome and what would need to change for a different outcome.

To appeal a decision, write to info@acceleratedscience.org within 30 days of the decision. Identify the point you believe is wrong and explain why. A person will re-read the paper and the relevant decision record. The response will state what was re-examined. If an error changed the outcome, the decision is corrected.