Review
Editorial Accountability
Who answers for a decision and what a decision contains.
Who Signs a Decision
Acceptances are reviewed and signed by a named editor, who is accountable for the decision. All other decisions follow the same published criteria and identify the specific rule applied, allowing authors to understand and trace the basis for each outcome.
What a Decision Contains
Each decision begins with a clear statement of the outcome, followed by an explanation in plain language. The relevant assessment checks are identified alongside the reasons. Every decision other than acceptance also explains what would need to change for a different outcome.
Correcting a Decision
Authors may appeal decisions based on factual errors, such as a misreading of the manuscript, an incorrectly identified reference, or a stated reason that does not apply to the submission. A human reviewer examines the relevant material, and the response identifies what was reviewed and explains the findings.