Review
Reviewer Guidelines
Assess the paper against the published criteria.
Assessing the Paper
- Is the reasoning valid on its own terms?
- For an empirical paper, does the design identify what the paper claims it identifies?
- Do the methods support the claims made from them?
- Are the sources real, correctly cited and correctly characterised?
- Is the contribution stated accurately?
What Is Not a Reason to Reject
A paper will not be rejected solely because its theory appears unrealistic, its mathematics is simple or complex, its writing lacks elegance or its topic does not interest the reviewer. Disagreement with a conclusion is not grounds for rejection if the evidence supports it. However, unsupported conclusions, implausible assumptions or inferences that the data cannot justify are legitimate grounds for rejection. Such deficiencies must be clearly identified and explained.
For theoretical research, strong assumptions are not inherently a weakness. For empirical research, however, an implausible assumption that is essential to identifying the claimed effect can undermine the validity of the findings.
Reports
Reports are written to be read by the author. Where a report is published, it appears in full alongside the paper with the reviewer's consent.