Standards
Policy Summary
The editorial and publishing policies that apply to every journal.
Criteria
The same criteria apply in every journal and every submission. Assessment covers the domain, method and argument: whether the work makes an original contribution to its subject, whether the empirical and analytical methods support the claims and whether the reasoning is sound and coherent. Within those three, papers are read for reasoning, evidence, methods, originality, transparency and contribution, and for nothing else. The criteria are published before submissions open and are not varied for individual papers.
Review
Every submission is screened, classified and assessed by a panel of AI reviewers against the published criteria. An acceptance is signed by a named editor. Any other outcome is issued from the panel’s assessment without prior review by an editor, and the reasons are stated to the author.
Editorial Independence
Assessment is kept separate from commercial consideration. Ownership of a journal confers no influence over the decision on any paper. Payment and waiver status are held in a separate system and cannot be read by anyone assessing a paper.
Research Integrity and Misconduct
Allegations of plagiarism, data fabrication, undisclosed conflicts or authorship abuse are investigated on the record. Where a concern is upheld after publication, the article carries the corresponding notice.
Corrections and Retractions
Three kinds of notice are available: correction, expression of concern, and retraction. Corrections, expressions of concern and retractions remain permanently linked to the article. Published versions remain available. No published article is silently altered or removed. Each notice identifies who was responsible for the error, including when the journal itself was responsible.
Conflicts of Interest
Financial and non-financial conflicts of interest that could bear on a paper are declared by its authors and by anyone who assesses it. Declarations are published with the article.
Data and Code
For a paper that reports data, the data and code behind the result are required. Deposit them in a durable repository and cite the deposit. Any restriction on access is stated and justified on the article.
Licensing and Copyright
Authors retain copyright. Publication is under CC BY 4.0 unless a funder mandates otherwise. The licence is stated on the article page.
AI Use
Use of AI carries no penalty. Disclosure is requested where the use affects how the results should be read.
Fees and Waivers
The standard submission fee is US$125 or US$25 for a verified educational email. The applicable fee is charged when the paper is initially submitted. Waivers are described on the Fees and Waivers page and must be requested before payment. A waiver cannot be applied afterwards because fees are non-refundable. There is no publication charge. Payment is held separately from assessment and is invisible to anyone assessing the paper.
Privacy
An email address is collected to operate sign-in and to return decisions. Uploaded files belong to the account that uploaded them. Retention follows ordinary journal practice.